After partnering with Penn Entertainment in 2020, Barstool dove head-first into the sports betting industry, launching Barstool Sportsbook later that year. In August 2021, Barstool Sportsbook took their operation to New Jersey, adding to the state’s already vast sports betting landscape.
In that same year, NJ reported $10.9 billion in sports betting revenue, and the state’s growth in the betting industry continues to climb with each passing year. However, Barstool closed in November 2023 to make way for ESPN Bet.
In this review, we’ll cover all the information you needed to know before signing up for Barstool Sportsbook in New Jersey and share our expert opinion on the betting operator.
Barstool’s welcome bonus got you off and running, but that was far from the only promotion at your disposal. While Barstool consistently offered similar promos throughout the year, it’s important to note that they offered special promotions from time to time as well. Here were the most common.
No, Barstool Sportsbook is not legal in New Jersey. Barstool launched their NJ sportsbook in August 2021, but then closed it in November 2023.
Signing up for Barstool Sportsbook was a straightforward process that didn't take very long at all. As long as you had a laptop or mobile device with internet access, signing up didn't take longer than 10 minutes. Here are the steps you needed to take.
Placing wagers through Barstool Sportsbook’s betting app was often the most convenient way to bet with the operator. Both the mobile app and website looked fairly similar, making it easy to navigate for users.
Barstool’s app was available for download on both iOS and Android devices. It was one of the highest-rated New Jersey betting apps in the Apple Store, with a firm 4.7/5 rating. However, the reviews weren't as glowing on the Google Play Store, where Barstool Sportsbook sat with a 3/5 rating.
The Barstool Sportsbook app was free to download.
How you could download the Barstool Sportsbook app on Apple devices
How you could download the Barstool Sportsbook app on Android devices
Barstool Sportsbook accepted a fair amount of deposit methods, but not quite as many as you expected. New Jersey’s deposit/withdrawal methods were similar to those found in other states.
Deposit methods for Barstool Sportsbook included:
Withdrawal methods included:
How you made a deposit
To make a deposit on Barstool Sportsbook, you opened up the app or web browser and headed to the top-right corner where you saw a money symbol; you clicked it to get started. There, you tapped or clicked the blue “Deposit” button right under your wallet balance.
After hitting “Deposit,” you were asked which payment method you’d like to use. Then, you were given the option to add $25, $50, $100, or a custom amount to your balance. Once you selected how much you’d like to deposit, scrolled to the bottom of the screen and selected “Deposit [amount].” Any transactions made through the Barstool Sportsbook app (deposit or withdrawal) must have been at least $10.
How you made a withdrawal
Although Barstool only offered three methods for withdrawing money from their betting app, the process was very similar to the depositing method.
First, you opened the betting app and clicked the money symbol in the top-right corner of the screen. You selected “Withdraw” and chose which method you’d like to use. Then, you’d enter how much money you’d like to take out.
According to Barstool’s FAQ page, it could take up to 14 business days to receive your money if it was a check and 2-3 days if you went the online banking route.
As you’d probably expect, Barstool Sportsbook offered a wide variety of sports to bet on, both domestically and internationally. With 15 sports to choose from across several different leagues, Barstool had something to satisfy every bettor.
Here were the top options available in NJ.
No, Barstool Sportsbook did not have a retail location in New Jersey.
With Penn Entertainment’s backing, there were a few logical locations where Barstool Sportsbook could set up shop. The most obvious was Freehold Raceway in Freehold, NJ. Penn Entertainment currently owns half of that venue.
Although Barstool Sportsbook was still in its infancy - launching just three years ago - it quickly became a go-to sportsbook in New Jersey and it’s easy to see why. Their wide variety of betting markets appeased both veteran bettors and newcomers alike. The app interface was simple in design, making it easy to navigate for beginners, while still packing enough depth to satisfy long-time bettors as well.
We particularly enjoyed their promotion variety, specifically Barstool’s Baseball Casino feature. Combining their online casino with their sportsbook seemed like an obvious move, but you were hard-pressed to find another sportsbook with a similar offer. This attention to creativity within the sports betting landscape made Barstool Sportsbook stand out from their competitors.
However, Barstool’s betting app was not perfect. Withdrawing money was somewhat of a hassle when it should have been an easy, straightforward process. With only three withdrawal options to choose from and two of them taking multiple days to process, withdrawing money became more of a nuisance when it should be the most rewarding aspect of the betting experience.
Nevertheless, this was a small hiccup with an otherwise stellar betting product.
